We are developing the social individualist meta-context for the future. From the very serious to the extremely frivolous... lets see what is on the mind of the Samizdata people.

Samizdata, derived from Samizdat /n. - a system of clandestine publication of banned literature in the USSR [Russ.,= self-publishing house]

An article claiming to explain Stephen Miller’s motivations that does not mention the Duke Lacrosse team

Stephen Miller has recently been appointed as Donald Trump’s new White House Chief of Staff. In an article for the Guardian called “How the rightwing operative David Horowitz shaped Stephen Miller”, Sidney Blumenthal, a former senior adviser to President Clinton and later to Hillary Clinton, writes,

Miller’s superiority complex neatly complements Trump’s malignant narcissism. Trump is Miller’s calling; Trumpism is his profession. His life has led to this consummation. Miller feels most superior, most himself, servicing Trump’s megalomania.

Miller is far more than a yes-man extraordinaire. Miles Taylor, the chief of staff at the Department of Homeland Security in the first Trump term, recalls being present when, after a lower federal court decision went against the administration, Trump banged his desk. “We need to get rid of the judges,” he reportedly said. In Taylor’s account, Miller piped up: “Yes sir, a country without judges would help.”

Miller projects his superiority complex as more than the lament of the lonely truth-teller. He debases opponents as “dumb”, “stupid”, “ignorant” and “foolish”.

Blumenthal has obviously delved deeply into Miller’s life. He talks about Miller’s father, his school and his relationship with Horowitz. Then he writes,

After Miller graduated from Duke, where he used the Horowitz front group, Students for Academic Freedom, to attack multiculturalism and liberalism as the campus crank

Blumenthal knows. It would be impossible for him – it would be impossible for anyone – to have researched Stephen Miller’s life in enough detail to be able to quote the exact words of Miller’s pitch when running for the student council of Santa Monica High School and not to have come across any mention of the experience that brought Miller to national prominence, and which Miller described as his greatest achievement while at college.

Blumenthal knows, but he doesn’t want to tell his readers that the blindingly obvious reason why Miller thinks of himself as a lonely truth-teller against the delusions of the leftist establishment is that he remembers being a lonely truth teller against the delusions of the leftist establishment. He remembers standing up – as a twenty year-old undergraduate – for the right to a fair trial of three fellow-students at Duke University accused of rape who were subjected to a worldwide media frenzy of denunciation, led by 88 members of Duke’s own faculty.

As it turned out, the three members of the Duke University Lacrosse team were innocent:

The Duke lacrosse rape hoax was a widely reported 2006 criminal case and racial scam in Durham, North Carolina, United States, in which three members of the Duke University men’s lacrosse team were falsely accused of rape. The three students were David Evans, Collin Finnerty, and Reade Seligmann. The accuser, Crystal Mangum, a student at North Carolina Central University] and part-time striptease dancer, alleged that the rape occurred at the Durham residence of two of the team’s captains, where she had worked on March 13, 2006. Investigation and resolution of the case sparked public discussion of racism, sexual violence, media bias, and due process on campuses. The former lead prosecutor, Durham County district attorney Mike Nifong, ultimately resigned in disgrace and was disbarred and briefly imprisoned for violating ethics standards. It was not until December 2024, 18 years after the events that Mangum admitted she had lied.

Miller did not know that they were innocent at the time, of course. What he was defending was their right to the presumption of innocence. He was right to do so.

I knew who Stephen Miller was in 2006. I rather think that Sidney Blumenthal did too.

Samizdata quote of the day – Scotland dials the dystopia up to 11

In April 2025, (a Free Speech Union) member — let’s call him Craig — was driving his four-year-old son home to Glasgow after a day out at an amusement park in Falkirk when another car cut him up as he was exiting the M80. Craig had to swerve to avoid a collision. He suspected the other driver was drunk and called the police from his car.

Both vehicles eventually stopped, and the police arrived. They declined to breathalyse either driver, but took Craig’s dashcam footage to investigate whether any laws had been broken.

A week later, officers contacted Craig to tell him that an offence had indeed been committed — by him, not the reckless driver.

His “crime” was muttering the words “smelly black bastard” under his breath seconds after almost being driven off the road. The windows were closed, so nobody outside the car could have heard him. The other driver was not looking in his direction and could not have seen him say it. The only person who might have heard was Craig’s four-year-old son in the back.

– Max Thompson

Samizdata quote of the day – Police state Britain, online edition

People seem to be widely unaware of the scope of UK indecent images law. This is exacerbated, I submit, by the activist-prosecutorial language of “Child Sexual Abuse Material” in discussion shortened to ‘CSAM’ which in Britain covers any arguably indecent (undefined, indecency being a fact for the court, hence “arguably”) image, however generated, of a minor, real or entirely fictional. Despite connoting in the public mind the most horrific crimes that are included, no actual child, nor representation of sex, nor actual physical or psychological abuse, is required for images to be deemed CSAM in Britain.

– Guy Herbert

Samizdata quote of the day – Riotous Assemblies (a history of recent English aggro)

The subject of public disorder seems strangely topical, as I’m writing as rioting in France quietens down. Events in Paris and elsewhere have, inevitably, prompted a number of “what if?” comparisons with the UK. Our tradition of protest is significantly different from that of continental Europe, but that doesn’t mean we can afford to be complacent. On the other hand, nor is it necessarily a reason for panicky chief constables and sly mandarins to litigate for mega-forces, national police services and gendarmeries.

– Dominic Adler, discussing Blighty’s recent history of crowds kicking off. Part 1 is here, Part 2 is here.

Samizdata quote of the day – A lovely example of the costs of bureaucracy

Why are such “small” sites not viable for the large developers? More pertinently perhaps, why are there not small developers who choose to build on sites of such scale? Because the bureaucracy – that interminable fight through the local council to gain planning, the demands for most of the profit to arrive as social housing and on and on – means that no small scale builder can survive. It’s necessary to be operating at a large scale to pay for all of that. You simply have to be a large organisation, building at scale, to be able to afford the army of your own bureaucrats necessary to fight the state.

So, abolish that bureaucracy and small scale builders will reappear and those 850,000 homes will be built.

850,000 houses missing in London alone. That’s what the current planning system denies us all. Probably a good idea to fire the bureaucrats and have the houses instead.

– Tim Worstall

Samizdata quote of the day – Capital Flight & Financial Repression

Once investors begin to doubt the real return available on sovereign liabilities, the speed with which they can respond becomes important. Modern financial wealth can be reallocated almost instantaneously. An investor dissatisfied with cash or government bonds can move into foreign equities, commodities, gold, property funds or another currency without waiting for wages, consumer prices or conventional money velocity to adjust. Monetary distrust can therefore appear first as a portfolio movement rather than as an immediate surge in spending on goods. This makes attempts to suppress sovereign yields potentially less stable. The wider the gap between the return investors believe they require and the return governments are willing to permit, the stronger the incentive to move elsewhere. In earlier periods, geographical, institutional and technological frictions slowed that process. Today, capital can react to a deterioration in expected real returns within seconds.

– Harry Yew

Samizdata quote of the day – What could possibly go wrong (German edition)?

Do we have any historical data on what happens when a German Chancellor abolishes the concept of free speech? I’m assuming it goes really well.

– Wings over Scotland

Samizdata quote of the day – should this be called the “Fuck OfCom Act”?

The HOMEFRONT Act is a GRANITE-style foreign censorship shield bill, the seventh such GRANITE-architecture bill or model policy to be advanced by American legislators in the last seven months, and the third such bill to be advanced in the last ten days. I anticipate there will be even more GRANITE-style bills, both state and federal, in the next several months.

– Preston Byrne

Samizdata quote of the day – What we really saw at the Portsmouth migrant boat protest

What we witnessed in Portsmouth was a public explosion of the deepest fissure in British society right now. On one side stands a state that has abdicated its prime responsibility, which is to defend Britain’s territory and Britain’s people from external forces. And on the other stand everyday citizens enraged by this managed suicide of British statehood, by the sacrifice of our sovereignty at the altar of a phoney globalist virtue that says borders are bigotry and migration is splendid.

A Home Office whistleblower has said what many of us have suspected for some time: that the vast majority of “asylum seeker” claims are false. In fact, he says, only around one per cent are genuine. For the state to keep foisting strong, fit, aggy men onto communities that don’t want them, while barking “They’re asylum seekers, you racists”, is wicked and preposterous. If the state wants to put a stop to the kind of vigilantism we saw in Portsmouth, then it just needs to do one simple thing: its job.

– Brendan O’Neill

The phone that the government touted as having child safety “built in” actually builds in an open door to predators

“Ministers embraced the ‘world’s safest phone’. Then it unravelled” – an article by Georgina Quach in the Financial Times. She writes,

Rather than relying on apps to police harmful content, governments now want to intervene at the operating system level, so guardrails can get ahead of whichever app breaks on to the scene. 

That is why Keir Starmer in June presented an ultimatum to tech companies: install child nudity-blocking software in devices by September or face legislation and fines.

And there is no excuse for dithering, the government’s announcement implied. It said this tech had already been achieved by the British company SafeToNet. Ministers held up SafeToNet as proof point for the proposition that child safety can be built into phones universally and block nudity in real time.

But what appeared to the government to be an “oven-ready” fix is now running into difficulty, after the first smartphone to integrate SafeToNet technology was removed from sale following an investigation into the device’s safety risks. The HMD Fuse, sold by Vodafone, was launched last year as the “first smartphone that protects a child’s innocence by stopping nude content from being filmed, seen, shared and stored”. In January of this year, former ministers Peter Kyle and Jess Phillips starred in a video promoting the phone. Six months later, sales have been suspended.

Why? The answer is alarming:

Then, in July 2026, Moore discovered what he described as a different, serious flaw: an unauthorised person could potentially register as the guardian of another child’s handset and access its live location. According to Moore, the problem was that the pairing relied on the IMEI number, the unique serial code that identifies each handset. He said this number was predictable: part of the number was fixed and the rest could be systematically enumerated and plugged in. He said that meant he could “become the guardian of every child on the platform, which meant I basically had a live map of every child on the system at the time”. 

Samizdata quote of the day – thou shalt not say ‘nigger’ if white (even if asked to)

The N-word is very much the ultimate trigger-word right now. Despite this being a full article about this precise epithet, I am unable to easily use it. Just to be safe from malicious prosecution or algorithmic suppression, even free speech websites like the Daily Sceptic will generally use asterisks to obscure it as ‘n****r’, even though you all know perfectly well what full word the typography indicates. It’s not ‘number’ or ‘nectar’ (‘neuter’ might be quite appropriate, though).

– Steven Tucker, writing In Minnesota, words matter more than rape.

Words of Power lose their impact when overused or habitually misused, which is why “fascist” and “racist”, once useful categoric descriptions with specific meanings, now mean almost nothing beyond “someone I do not like and wish to place beyond the pale”.

However “nigger”, absolutely a word of power in a strangely inverted way, is just a crass insult. Yet it is so powerful we’re required to render it as “the N-word”, akin to saying “Adonai” rather than the true name of God. Yet bizarrely in this two-tier civilization of ours, it becomes acceptable when used by melanin enhanced rappers, in which case it becomes something more akin to “geezer” or “my crew” or various other non-taboo things, depending on context.

It’s a funny old world.

Mr Burnham, could you turn your attention to these scams next?

Our new Prime Minister is taking action to protect British people against unfair dealing.

“It should be just as easy to cancel a subscription as it is to start it. And if something is advertised as half price, it should actually be half price”, he says. Sounds fair.

Darren Jones is stuck paying for some subscriptions that he doesn’t use or want and has asked for Mr Burnham’s help:

And on the scourge of fake price reductions, Anna Ridgway asks,