I spent a couple of torpid hours on Tuesday afternoon listening to the billionaire hedge fund king and now globetrotting philanthropist George Soros give a talk to a British parliamentary committee. Soros is the man who, to the everlasting gratitude of the British public, attacked the pound sterling in the foreign exchange markets during September 1992, ejecting this country out of the European Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM), a move which allowed the pound to fall to a level that made it possible for British goods to be profitably sold abroad once more. So one might have thought that the Hungarian-born finance wizard would be a hero to this humble hack. Alas, the man has feet of clay, and very big lumps of clay at that.
Soros has spent the last few years ruminating about the many dangers of global capitalism, which is a bit like Formula One racing ace Michael Schumacher warning about the risks of high-speed motor racing. Soros thinks the globalisation of capitalism, while not without a few benefits, is full of dangers and problems, which require rules and international watchdogs to run things. Here are a few snippets:
“The major causes of poverty are bad governance and bad location.”
Well, I agree bad governments contribute to poverty, and there are dozens of examples of how collectivist regimes of various stripes have beggared their populaces and retarded wealth creation down the centuries. Take the current miserable example of Zimbabwe, for example. But bad location? Does Soros think that unfortunate geography causes poverty? Then how does he explain why places like Hong Kong, with hardly any natural resources apart from good shipping links, are fabulously wealthy, while most of Africa, with huge mineral wealth, subsides in misery? The same goes for large chunks of Asia and parts of Latin America.
“Governments are less well situated to provide public goods than they were because they cannot tax capital as they used to. We need to strengthen international institutions for the provision of public goods.”
Well, all I can say to that is – thank heaven for multinationals. By George, George has got it! International capital flows are cramping the ability of would-be socialist spend-it-like-water governments from doing what they used to do. The likes of British Prime Minister Tony Blair have been forced, through gritted teeth, to rein in old socialist habits on the knowledge that financial markets will punish those habits in a heartbeat.
George Soros is clearly a highly clever man when it comes to making dollops of money beyond most folks’ wildest dreams, but I fear that like many in his case, he has almost rebelled against the free market order in which he made his billions out of guilt or perhaps more honorably, out of a desire to help mankind from his lofty vantage point. It bears out the point I have sometimes heard in libertarian circles that capitalists often make the worst advocates of the classical liberal order.
